Role of endogenous oestrogen in aetiology of coronary heart disease: analysis of age related trends in coronary heart disease and breast cancer in England and Wales and Japa
BMJ 2002; 325 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.325.7359.311 (Published 10 August 2002) Cite this as: BMJ 2002;325:311
- Debbie A Lawlor, MRC research training fellow (D.A.Lawlor{at}bristol.ac.uk),
- Shah Ebrahim, professor of epidemiology of ageing,
- George Davey Smith, professor of clinical epidemiology
- Correspondence to: D A Lawlor
- Accepted 12 February 2002
The sex difference in mortality from coronary heart disease decreases with increasing age, suggesting a protective effect of oestrogen in premenopausal women. This decrease is, however, the result of a deceleration in death rates in men, with no change in rates in women around the age of menopause.1 The age specific rate of breast cancer—a condition associated with endogenous oestrogen—does show a change around the age of menopause among women in the United States.2 The relatively low rates of coronary heart disease in premenopausal women may make it difficult to detect an effect of the menopause.3 Rates of breast cancer among Japanese women are low. If low rates of coronary heart disease around the time of the menopause explain the lack of an effect of the menopause on age related trends then no effect of the menopause on breast cancer trends among Japanese women might be expected.
Methods and results
We obtained data on age specific mortality from coronary heart disease (ICD-9 (international classification of diseases, 9th revision): 410-414) for women and men and from breast cancer (ICD-9: 174) for women in England and Wales from the Office for National Statistics and in Japan from the World Health Organization. We calculated five year aggregate rates for each country (1994-8 for England and Wales and 1993-7 for Japan) and plotted them on a semilogarithmic scale.
Coronary heart disease mortality in women from both countries increased with age, and in both countries the death rate in men decelerated at older ages, reducing the magnitude of the sex difference (figure). We found no inflection in age specific mortality from coronary heart disease in women around the age of menopause in either England and Wales or Japan. In contrast, mortality from breast cancer began to decelerate around the time of the menopause in both groups.
Age specific trends in mortality from coronary heart disease in men and women and from breast cancer in women. Aggregated data for England and Wales (top) and Japan (bottom)
Comment
Mortality from breast cancer in Japanese women is about half that from coronary heart disease in women in England and Wales at ages 45-54; it is thus unlikely that the low mortality from coronary heart disease makes detection of a menopause effect difficult. The inflection in breast cancer mortality occurs over a narrow age range, suggesting that if effects of menopausal oestrogen on coronary heart disease occurred they too should operate over a similar range and be observable. However, coronary heart disease is associated with several environmental risk factors, and if the effect of oestrogen on risk of coronary heart disease is small relative to other risk factors then any effect of the menopause may be masked.
Witteman et al argue that age related trends in coronary heart disease mortality are not inconsistent with an effect of the menopause.4 They used simulation models based on levels of risk of coronary heart disease in men to estimate age related trends in “women who never experience a menopause.”4 Such analyses are unrealistic and unhelpful.
Work on the aetiology of coronary heart disease in women has been dominated by the idea that oestrogen plays an important part and is responsible for the sex difference at younger ages. The implications of this are that higher rates of coronary heart disease in men are seen as inevitable and that postmenopausal hormone replacement therapy has become the mainstay of coronary heart disease prevention in women. We conclude that environmental factors are the most important determinants of coronary heart disease in women and men and of the difference in coronary heart disease rates between women and men.5
Acknowledgments
Contributors: All authors conceived the idea for the study. DAL undertook the analysis and wrote the first draft of the paper. All authors contributed to the final report. DAL will act as guarantor.
Footnotes
-
Funding DAL is an MRC research training fellow and is funded by the Medical Research Council. Views expressed are those of the authors.
-
Competing interests None declared.